Skip to main content

Report: The Majority of TDIs May not be Worth Fixing

Now that US district Judge Charles M Breyer has approved Volkswagen’s TDI settlement, the question of what will happen to the cars that are bought back remains. It turns out that roughly 325,000 older diesel Volkswagens may be cheaper to scrap to than to fix.

That’s according to recent report from Green Car Reports, that argues that the oldest, worst polluting TDIs aren’t equipped with many of the physical parts that might make later model TDIs easy to fix.

The TDI Jettas, Golfs, Passats, and Beetles produced in 2015 came from the factory fitted with tanks for Diesel Emission Fluid that’s required in selective catalytic reduction exhaust after treatment (which reduces NOx). Besides the fact that the new EA288 TDI engines were the least polluting engines to begin with, this tank will likely make it easy and cheap to modify the 2015 TDIs into compliance. Same goes for the 2012-2014 Passat.

2015_jetta_tdi_4218-3

A range of Golfs, Beetles, and Jettas produced between 2009 and 2014, on the other hand, don’t have those tanks. On top of that, they were equipped with the most polluting engine, so fixing them might require fitting new parts.

Retrofitting the approximately 325,000 cars with parts they were never designed to have may turn out to be more expensive than just buying them back.

What happens remains to be seen, as an expected proposal for a fix to these very cars is coming up on November 11 (though the final deadline set at January 27, 2017).

1.6 TDI Motor ( EA 189 ): Strömungsgleichrichter (Einbau: Bild 1 von 6)

If, indeed, it turns out that just buying all the cars back is cheaper, VW will have a couple of options for what to do with them then, as per the agreement.

The manufacturer’s first option is to recycle the cars, by essentially parting them out.

The second option is to sell them abroad, where emissions regulations are less stringent. Although this sounds like a workaround, it may be less environmentally damaging to keep these polluting cars on the road, as the environmental toll of producing half a million new cars to replace the scrapped TDIs is great.

Finally, for the newer cars with a theoretically financially viable fix, the same two options apply, though they would have a third option: resell the cars in the US, presumably at a discount, with proper disclosure.

[source: Green Car Report]

The post Report: The Majority of TDIs May not be Worth Fixing appeared first on VWVortex.



from VWVortex http://ift.tt/2fgZb5E
via IFTTT

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Project SportWagen: Going Stage 2 with APR

    When we last left you, the humble little SportWagen was fresh from the development process with our friends at AWE Tuning, sporting a new downpipe, exhaust and intake, allowing things to breathe a bit easier.  The car sounded great, but there was no getting around the fact that our wagon was still quite, well, slow.   While we realize that nothing we do to the Golf SportWagen at this point will make it a race car, we still felt compelled to do something .  To put it bluntly, we had a fever, and the only cure was more power. Flash forward a few hours, and we found ourselves at Waterfest, staring down APR’s palatial spread and the numerous tuned vehicles surrounding it.  Earlier in the year, APR had hinted to us that their 1.8 TSI files would be quite impressive, and based on what they were able to do with the 2.0 TSI found in the new GTI and our time in their Golf R, we knew it’d be worth the wait.  So with this in mind, we lined our G...

Project Golf SportWagen- Intro

I’ve never really been one for SUVs and crossovers.  The current offerings aren’t the body-on-frame, go-anywhere specialty tools I remember from my youth, and what they lack in capability, they also lack in on-road performance. The current crop isn’t terribly good at handling or being efficient, which in my opinion are major components of our ideal driving experience.  So when it comes to space or utility, I usually look for something of the wagon variety- and it seems that I’m not alone. We hit quite a few shows around the east coast each summer, and we see modified Jetta SportWagens at nearly every event. Even amongst common consumers, these cars are highly sought-after. They don’t depreciate much, making even early Mk 5 2.5 versions expensive in comparison to other Jettas or Golfs of the same vintage. This year, Volkswagen launched their latest SportWagen, which is now billed as a Golf.  In many ways, this latest SportWagen is the best yet and it has certai...

Volkswagen Group Records Best Ever First-Half-of-Year Sales

With 5.5 million vehicles in customer hands after the first six months of 2018, the Volkswagen Group is seeing the best performance of its history. Group deliveries increased significantly in all core regions,” said Fred Kappler, head of sales for the Group. “Our core brands recorded strong growth in the first half year.” For the year-to-date, all of Volkswagen’s brands had sales bumps. MAN, SEAT, and Skoda led the sales charge with performances 24%, 17% and 11% better than the previous year. The big sellers, too, had strong sales periods, with Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles, Audi, and Volkswagen sales rising 3.5%, 4.5% and 6.3% respectively. That last figure is particularly good new for the board, since Volkswagen alone sold more than 3 million vehicles in the first half of 2018. As Kappler stated, the numbers are equally good when you break sales down by region. Brazil and Russia were the most improved markets (22% and 20%, respectively), while strong sales in Europe and China (u...