Skip to main content

Carfection Asks Which GTI is the Best GTI

With the 40th anniversary of the GTI coming quickly, many people are looking back on the car’s history. Carfection’s Alex Goy has assembled one of each generation of Golf GTI and tested them back to back to decide which he likes best.

Goy praises every generation, saying he’d be happy with any of them, but one comes out on top: the Mk5.

“The Mk5 is a highlight,” says Goy. He praises it for its steering and its gear changes, but he says “the engine is my favorite bit.” It sounds nice, moves the car well, and the turbo is great. Many people, he remembers, called it the best car they had ever driven when it came out.

The Mk1, 2, 6, and 7 also garner praise from Goy for being fun and practical. “People say that hot hatch XYZ is quicker,” he explains, “but that’s not the point. It’s about being just right.” And they are.

Not every version of the car is praised, though. Goy makes it no secret that his least favorite models are the Mk3 and 4. He admits that they may be quick, but they commit the cardinal GTI sin of not being fun.

Regardless of how much you may agree with Goy, or how deeply you disagree, it’s fun to watch all seven GTIs on track and to be reminded of how good the GTI really is. Let us know which is your favorite GTI in comments.

The post Carfection Asks Which GTI is the Best GTI appeared first on VWVortex.



from VWVortex http://ift.tt/1WFSMio
via IFTTT

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2018 Lamborghini Aventador S Roadster Review

“Supercars just don’t excite me anymore.” These words, spoken to me over a month ago by another journalist, friend, and (so-called) enthusiast were echoing in my head for far too long, but they’ve finally been drowned out. Drowned out by the wail of a naturally aspirated 6.5-liter V12 engine mounted in the middle of the new Lamborghini Aventador S Roadster. My friend’s point is that back in the good old days, there was a crop of supercars that captured the imagination with amazing style, sounds, performance, and more. Today, it seems like everything is capable of supercar performance, with large luxury sedans outdoing some of the best and most dedicated teams of car nuts, while former pillars of automotive excellence are suddenly pumping out family-friendly SUVs. Beyond that, another league of supercars, dubbed hypercars have cropped up with hybrid gas-electric powertrains that make magical things happen quickly, but at the cost of the acoustic drama, visual flair, and engag...

Project SportWagen: Going Stage 2 with APR

    When we last left you, the humble little SportWagen was fresh from the development process with our friends at AWE Tuning, sporting a new downpipe, exhaust and intake, allowing things to breathe a bit easier.  The car sounded great, but there was no getting around the fact that our wagon was still quite, well, slow.   While we realize that nothing we do to the Golf SportWagen at this point will make it a race car, we still felt compelled to do something .  To put it bluntly, we had a fever, and the only cure was more power. Flash forward a few hours, and we found ourselves at Waterfest, staring down APR’s palatial spread and the numerous tuned vehicles surrounding it.  Earlier in the year, APR had hinted to us that their 1.8 TSI files would be quite impressive, and based on what they were able to do with the 2.0 TSI found in the new GTI and our time in their Golf R, we knew it’d be worth the wait.  So with this in mind, we lined our G...

Project Golf SportWagen- Intro

I’ve never really been one for SUVs and crossovers.  The current offerings aren’t the body-on-frame, go-anywhere specialty tools I remember from my youth, and what they lack in capability, they also lack in on-road performance. The current crop isn’t terribly good at handling or being efficient, which in my opinion are major components of our ideal driving experience.  So when it comes to space or utility, I usually look for something of the wagon variety- and it seems that I’m not alone. We hit quite a few shows around the east coast each summer, and we see modified Jetta SportWagens at nearly every event. Even amongst common consumers, these cars are highly sought-after. They don’t depreciate much, making even early Mk 5 2.5 versions expensive in comparison to other Jettas or Golfs of the same vintage. This year, Volkswagen launched their latest SportWagen, which is now billed as a Golf.  In many ways, this latest SportWagen is the best yet and it has certai...